Five years of Alchemy

Do you have a real relationship with your fans?

Year five at Alchemy, and what we now believe about monetizing music.

TikTok almost disappeared from U.S. app stores twice. Both times, artists with one hundred or one million followers had no way to tell those followers where to find them next. During both events, they reported app glitches and stood by, helpless, with their years of content and followers on the brink of extinction. And for what? The audience they were about to lose was never theirs, and it was never worth as much as the follower count suggested.

TikTok is not the discovery engine we give it credit for. YouTube leads, with 52% of consumers naming it a top-three place to find new music, ahead of streaming platforms (40%) and TikTok (37%). And the people who do find a song there rarely become listeners. Fewer than half of TikTok users go on to stream a song they found there, and fewer than one in four are still listening four months later (MIDiA Research).

At best, that is an introduction. An introduction is not a relationship.

The old offerings made sense

In our previous management roles, we watched artists' digital marketing needs grow and evolve every day. Managers, labels, agents, and promoters are each responsible for a piece of an artist's career, and the work that falls between them often goes undone. We started Alchemy to do that work, and to follow the gap wherever it moved.

When the pandemic took artists off the road, and they were met with content mandates, we built for that moment: short-form content, channel management, and social strategy. It made sense at the time. TikTok was the most powerful awareness tool the business had seen in years, and what it does uniquely well is amplify: 84% of songs that entered the Billboard Global 200 in 2024 went viral on TikTok first. It still introduces artists to new listeners, but an introduction is not a relationship. We now spend our time on what comes after a fan meets an artist they love.

Five years in, two core beliefs now drive our work.

iInvest in improving the direct-to-fan experience. Fans will invest back in the art.
iiCollaborate on marketing that monetizes music. Everyone earns more, whether they are paid on the song or on the ticket.

What happens after the follow?

Artists should be able to earn a living from music without being stars. Both of Alchemy's core beliefs are about revenue, so the question we focus on now is: what happens after a fan follows an artist? We believe that the answer determines whether the artist gets paid. We see three places where that money is either earned or left on the table.

01

The owned channel

A social media follower belongs to the social media platform. A phone number or an email address belongs to the artist. If the social platform disappears, a follower is gone. A subscriber is still one text away. Closing the gap between social follower and subscriber was most of our work in 2026.

To turn a follower into a subscriber, give the fan a better experience instead of asking for a favor:

Reduce friction. Before a tour on-sale, fans RSVP by phone or email through Laylo and get the presale code by text automatically.

Offer something exclusive. Early access, presale codes, and perks that followers on a social platform do not get.

Let fans weigh in. Fans who are asked what they want tend to invest back in the art.

Direct-to-fan turns attention into a list the artist owns. An owned list sells the next ticket, record, and merch drop without renting the audience again.

02

The catalog

Catalog is 76% of U.S. on-demand audio streaming, yet most of it is administered, not marketed: rights registered, licenses cleared, royalties collected. The songs doing most of the streaming get the least marketing support. Catalog deserves release-grade marketing attention, and not just on anniversaries.

Proactive. Anniversaries, pre-release windows, and seasons are dates a team can see coming. A campaign for a 1990s reggae classic ran ahead of its seasonal ramp, not into the peak. One year later, with no additional spend, the song held a 42% lift in YouTube views.

Reactive. No one can plan a viral moment, but a team with a reactive catalog plan can redirect one. When an unauthorized AI remix of Stick Figure's "Angels Above Me" went viral and hit No. 1 on iTunes in six countries, the band's team, ours included, pointed that attention back to the original master. Nearly six months later, the song still streams at 3.8X its pre-remix daily average.

Collaborative. A label, a publisher, a rights firm, and a distributor all earn on the same stream, and none of them can run the campaign alone. The artist holds the platform access, the label holds the largest budget, and the publisher's share is often too thin to fund a campaign by itself.

A catalog marketed on an annual calendar turns songs that already exist into royalties that keep moving "up and to the right," quarter after quarter.

03

Hard ticket sales

Demand for live music is not why seats go unsold. Live Nation drew 61 million fans in the third quarter, up 19%, and expects nearly 180 million for the year (Live Nation). Goldman Sachs projects live music revenue will grow from $37.4 billion in 2025 to nearly $65 billion by 2035 (Music in the Air). Seats go unsold because the chain of custody on the fan is broken.

The artist team owns the email list and the marketing pixel. The ticketing company and whoever holds the ticketing account, usually the promoter or the venue, keep the buyer data. The artist's pixel reaches the ticketing page only if that account holder agrees to place it. National promoters usually decline, citing company policy against third-party pixels. Every party holds a piece of the fan record, and no one holds the whole. The result is missed marketing opportunities, unreached fans, and unsold tickets.

Touring needs a different approach, one that connects the artist team, the promoter, and the venue. A connected tour works around that gap in three ways:

Reduce purchase friction. Fans RSVP once and the presale code arrives by text.

Treat venues as marketing partners. The agent's ticket counts show which markets need help. Every venue gets one page with the approved assets and copy, plus a report of what the artist team spent in its market, ready to reimburse at settlement.

Create value between tours. Value does not have to mean an online store discount. On the I HOPE THIS HELPS Tour, Alana Springsteen and To Write Love On Her Arms used SET.Live to give one fan at every show three hours of free therapy through BetterHelp.

A connected tour sells more seats at a lower cost per ticket and builds the presale list for the next run.

What's next: marketing that monetizes music

We believe in the middle-class musician and a collaborative music industry. This future is built on fans you can communicate with directly, not followers you rent. We ask three things of the industry: let artists own the channel, give catalog the marketing it has earned, and connect the touring chain so the artist team, the promoter, and the venue share the fan record. None of it needs an algorithm's permission, and all of it pays better when the people paid on the same song or ticket plan together. An introduction gets an artist noticed. What happens after it is how they get paid, and that is where we will spend year six.

The series

Five years of Alchemy

Read part onei
Five Years of AlchemyWhat we now believe about monetizing music
Part twoii
CatalogComing soon
Part threeiii
TourComing soon